Posted by u/runningfromcardio·2 months ago·Hot Take

Is an RD + sports nutritionist combo worth it for CrossFit Games prep?

TL;DR: Is having both an RD and a sports nutritionist overkill for CrossFit prep?

So, I've been lifting for about a year and run sprints like they're my life, but I'm thinking of stepping up my game for the CrossFit scene. I've heard mixed things about having an RD work alongside a sports nutritionist, especially for high-level competition.

Do you think it's necessary to have both in my corner, or can one do the job just fine? Im just trying to avoid any nutrition mishaps that could totally throw me off my gains or worse, like missing out on a sweet PR day. What do y'all think?

22 comments

Comments

u/no_caffeine_needed·2 months ago

Honestly, I think relying on both an RD and a sports nutritionist might be overkill. RDs are great for general nutrition, but they may not understand the unique demands of CrossFit. You might find that one of them can meet your needs just fine. Plus, too many cooks in the kitchen could confuse your approach. Have you considered just consulting with someone who specializes in sports nutrition for a tailored plan?

199

u/depressedlifter·2 months ago

I've been in a similar boat and let me tell you, missing out on gains sucks! I tried to DIY my nutrition before and it was a mess. I'd suggest at least consulting an RD to avoid my mistakes. You don't want to deal with the aftermath of bad nutrition.

u/no_caffeine_needed·2 months ago

A sports nutritionist might be beneficial, but it's important to vet their experience with CrossFit. I've heard stories of athletes being misled by generic advice. An RD with a sports performance background might actually cover both bases.

u/calisthenics_dude·2 months ago

If your goal is peak performance, both could cover you well. An RD will help with overall health while a sports nutritionist can dive into the specifics like timing meals and macros. It's all about how you want to tailor your prep.

u/sweaty_sarah·2 months ago

I love the idea of getting both an RD and a sports nutritionist! It sounds like a power team. If you can swing it financially, having different perspectives could really up your game. Plus, more knowledge is always better!

u/6footdadbod·2 months ago

I gotta say, sometimes simpler is better. If your diet is already solid, just stick with a good sports nutritionist. An RD can be overkill if you're just looking for a few tweaks!

u/runningfromcardio·2 months ago

Honestly, I can't imagine having both! Seems like a lot, especially if u're just starting to prep for the Games. Focus on nailing your routine first, then think about consulting someone.

u/veganpowerlift99·2 months ago

Plant-based options can be super beneficial too! I know my vegan gains have been legit with the right nutrition. If you're leaning towards having both, maybe a vegan sports nutritionist could give you unique insights!

u/no_caffeine_needed·2 months ago

Having both an RD and a sports nutritionist can feel excessive, but it really depends on your specific needs. RDs typically cover overall health and dietary concerns, while sports nutritionists focus on performance. If you're aiming for the CrossFit Games, nuanced support might be key, but I wonder if you can get similar value from just one of them

u/powerlifting_panda·16 days ago

There's no one-size-fits-all here, but considering your goals, having both could help you reach peak performance. Just ensure they're in sync with your training plan. It might save you a lot of headaches down the road.

u/proteinpancakes22·2 months ago

Protein pancakes for breakfast? Yes, please! But seriously, I think it's great that you want to focus on nutrition too. Just make sure whatever route u take includes plenty of protein and healthy carbs to support those intense workouts.

u/twenty_mile_tom·2 months ago

CrossFit is intense, and you want to be sure your nutrition aligns with your training. It can help to have experts in both fields, especially leading up to a competition. That way, you'll get a solid plan that covers all bases, including energy levels and recovery. Plus, they can keep each other in check on your plan. If you have the resources, i'd say go for it!

u/twenty_mile_tom·2 months ago

Just like training, nutrition needs a solid plan! I'd recommend having both an RD and a sports nutritionist on your team. They can tackle different aspects of your diet and ensure you're maximizing performance. Every detail counts when it comes to hitting those PRs!

u/running_on_empty·2 months ago

Honestly, balancing school and working out is tough enough for me, so I get where you're coming from! If you can afford both, maybe that's the way to go. But I think having a single expert who knows CrossFit specifically could work too.

u/grindhardnotfat·2 months ago

Having a diverse nutrition team can be smart, but don't forget about the basics! Quality whole foods and tracking macros are a must. You might not need both unless you're really struggling with specifics.

u/zone2_ninja·2 months ago

While some level of consultation with both might help, it's really all about how you plan your training and nutrition. If you have the data to back up your training metrics, you can streamline your nutrition accordingly. Check out some studies on performance nutrition!

u/strongbutawkward·2 months ago

I wouldn't stress too much about it. Nutrition can feel overwhelming, but sometimes it's about what works best for you. If you want to experiment with a nutritionist first, that could help you decide if you need an RD too.

u/spoonie_lifter·2 months ago

I get where you're coming from! I used to train with a sports nutritionist, and it was helpful to have someone who specialized in the demands of my workouts. But sometimes it can be too much info. You can still thrive with just one, especially if you find someone experienced in competitive CrossFit. Just make sure you're tracking what works for you, and listen to your body!

u/endurancejunkie99·2 months ago

From a long-distance running perspective, having a knowledgeable team is vital. I found that my performance improved significantly after working with a nutritionist. But balance is key, don't overload yourself with too many voices.

u/calisthenics_dude·2 months ago

Honestly, an RD can be good for overall health advice, but sports nutritionists will know the specifics for CrossFit. It's like knowing the difference between a general fitness plan and one tailored to your sport. A solid sports nutritionist can optimize your performance while keeping your body fueled for those heavy lifts and grueling WODs. Plus, they can help with hydration strategies, which is often overlooked.

u/spoonie_lifter·2 months ago

I totally get it, avoiding nutrition mishaps is so important! I have a chronic illness, and I found that having an RD helped me understand how to navigate my food choices better. If your budget allows, both could be really beneficial for a well-rounded approach.

u/6footdadbod·2 months ago

Why not just combine their strengths? One of them can cover your macros while the other focuses on meal timing and nutrient timing around workouts. It's like a tag team for your gains! Plus, you can always throw in some avocados to keep things fun. 🥑 Seriously though, if you're serious about competing, having both in your corner could set you up for success!