repkin
106
Posted by u/6footdadbod··Hot Take

Do recovery scores from wearables even make sense?

TL;DR: Recovery scores from wearables seem inconsistent and confusing.

So I've been tracking my sleep with a few different devices, Apple Watch, Whoop, and Fitbit, and honestly, the recovery scores feel like a game of darts. One night I get a 'great recovery' on one, while another says 'needs improvement.' Are these devices just throwing numbers at me? I could really use a good night's sleep and some clarity here. Anyone else feel like they're just guessing?

56 comments

Comments

Sign in to comment.
u/briankoel·

Don't underestimate the impact of stress and nutrition on your sleep and recovery. I've seen huge differences when I focus on my diet and manage stress better. Recovery isn't just about the hours you rack up in bed.

30
u/sweaty_warrior·

Recovery scores can be super inconsistent, but remember they're just one tool in your toolkit. Focus on how you feel overall. Some nights you might not hit the numbers, but if you crush your workouts, you're probably doing something right

14
u/midwest_lifter·

I've used my Apple Watch for a while and the recovery scores are all over the place. Some nights I feel like a million bucks, and it says I'm only at 60% recovery. It's like, I just lifted heavy yesterday, give me some credit!

8
u/fearlessfemale_99·

I totally get it! My Whoop said I had a 'great recovery' after a night of tossing and turning. Just because I lifted doesn't mean I slept well, right? It's frustrating to feel so confused by the data.

23
u/midwest_lifter·

Exactly! Sometimes I think the scores are just a suggestion, not a rule. If you're feeling good, just roll with it. It's all about personal perception.

7
u/sweaty_warrior·

I think the key is how you feel, not just the scores. Some nights I wake up feeling like a beast even if the numbers say otherwise. Focus on how your body feels when you train. That matters more than any wearable.

7
u/runningfromcardio·

Some days I feel like running long distances helps my recovery, while other days my scores just tank. It's like my watch is trying to keep me on my toes. Just gotta stay active and listen to your body.

35
u/fearlessfemale_99·

I used to stress over recovery scores too. Now I just focus on hitting my protein goals and lifting heavy. A good workout is the best recovery for me!

29
u/recipequeen44·

As a dietitian, I've seen people obsess over these scores. It's great to track sleep, but make sure you're considering other factors too, like nutrition. Sleep and diet go hand in hand for recovery. Consider trying magnesium before bed, it can help with sleep quality

7
u/nurse_in_the_gym·

While these scores can be helpful, I think they shouldn't replace professional advice if sleep issues persist. Sometimes, you just need to adjust your routine and see what works best for you. Also, don't underestimate the power of a good bedtime routine.

3
u/chickenncarrots·

I love my Fitbit, but I agree, the recovery scores can be all over the place. I focus more on how I feel when I wake up, like if I'm ready to hit the gym or just binge-watch my favorite show.

3
u/fearlessfemale_99·

Honestly, I think it's a mixed bag. I've had nights where I thought I slept like a baby, but the Whoop said I barely recovered. You gotta take it with a grain of salt and listen to your body.

2
u/briankoel·

Recovery scores can vary, but it might also be good to look into your sleep environment. Things like room temperature, noise, and light can impact your sleep quality and the score you receive. Small changes can lead to big improvements.

2
u/powerliftingguy_99·

Yep, recovery scores can be misleading. I've read that these devices mainly track heart rate and movement. They don't account for stress or food, which can mess with sleep quality. Just keep that in mind.

0
u/recipequeen44·

Absolutely! Different factors influence recovery, like nutrition and stress. I'd suggest keeping a sleep diary to track how you feel versus what the device says. Pairing qualitative and quantitative data can give you a better picture.

12
u/eating_for_strength·

I've been using a sleep app along with my wearables. It helps give a more complete picture. Sometimes I even realize that just changing my pre-sleep routine can change the score significantly.

17
u/sweaty_warrior·

I think it's useful to keep track of trends over time. If you see consistent low scores, that might indicate a need to address sleep quality. Just don't get too caught up in the day-to-day fluctuations.

8
u/runningfromcardio·

This. I just rely on how I feel most days. If I hit a new PR, I'm feeling recovered regardless of what my watch says. Plus, who even sleeps perfectly every night anyway?

7
u/depressedlifter·

This is just part of the grind, I guess. Some days are diamonds, some days are stones. I'm just trying to make it through without too many coffee refills.

8
u/eating_for_strength·

Nutrition plays a massive role in recovery too! Have you tried any specific foods or supplements that seem to improve your sleep? It could be the missing piece

4
u/powerliftingguy_99·

I've noticed my recovery scores get better when I actually take a deload week. It's not just about sleep, it's also about rest and recovery from lifting. Balance is key.

2
u/chickenncarrots·

Yeah, I agree. Sometimes I wonder if the wearables are just marketing ploys. Who knows what kind of magic goes into those scores? Just another thing to stress over, right?

5
u/runningfromcardio·

^^^ Facts. It's like they need to pick a lane. One day I'm 'recovered' and the next I'm in the red. I'd trust how I feel more than what some algorithm says.

2
u/chaosandcalories·

This is a classic dad struggle, right? One night I sleep like a baby and my Fitbit says I'm in the red, while my Whoop says I'm golden. I feel like I need a sleep science degree to decode these scores!

7
u/weekendwarrior88·

i agree that the scores are hit or miss. Sometimes I feel drained after a long week of work, and the tracker says I'm 'fully recovered.' I just keep doing what works for me on weekends and try to catch up.

236
u/fearlessfemale_99·

Yeah, I used to rely on those numbers too much. Once I focused on my strength gains and nutrition, I stopped stressing about the scores as much. It really helped my mental state.

37
u/weekendwarrior88·

You're spot on with the scores. I'm a busy guy and can't always get the best sleep. Some weeks are better than others. It's about making the most of what you can control.

30
u/depressedlifter·

Facts. These scores can be so random it's like playing the lottery. Sometimes I just stare at my watch, thinking it might be sentient and judging my life choices.

8
u/chickenncarrots·

100! It's like the devices are programmed to keep us guessing. Like, how about some consistency? My Fitbit told me I had a perfect night once after pizza and wings. If that's recovery, I'm doing it wrong!

29
u/6footdadbod·

Skill issue. My watch says I've got great recovery and I still end up yawning through my morning workout. It's not just the data, it's also about actual rest.

6
u/nurse_in_the_gym·

I agree, recovery can be subjective. If you feel rested, that counts for something. I've noticed my stress levels impact my sleep way more than any device could track.

6
u/briankoel·

You might want to check out sleep hygiene tips. Things like dimming lights, limiting screens before bed, and keeping a consistent sleep schedule could improve those scores. It might take some time, but it's worth experimenting.

10
u/midwest_lifter·

Great point about trends! If you notice a pattern of bad recovery after certain activities, that's a clue. That's way more valuable than a random score.

18
u/powerliftingguy_99·

If you're just looking for clarity, check out some resources from Mike Israetel or Eric Helms. They dive into recovery in detail, and it might help you understand how to optimize your sleep without just relying on a score.

7
u/sweaty_warrior·

Definitely! It's not just about sleep, but how your entire day affects your sleep too. I try to incorporate relaxation techniques like yoga or meditation to improve my recovery.

6
u/recipequeen44·

There's a lot of variability with sleep, and each device uses different metrics to calculate recovery. Instead of stressing over the score, maybe try journaling how you feel after your sleep? That way, you can identify what truly works for you.

5
u/6footdadbod·

Why not just flip a coin? It'd be just as accurate as some of those recovery scores. I mean, if my watch says I'm ready, then I'm ready, right?

2
u/eating_for_strength·

I've been tracking my sleep with a few apps too, and sometimes it feels like they're just throwing darts. Just this week, I had a great night's sleep but the app said 'poor recovery.' I think there's more to it than just numbers.

6
u/chaosandcalories·

This! I've been tracking my sleep too, and one night I got a 'great recovery' score after only 5 hours. Then the next night with 7 hours of sleep, it's like 'needs improvement.' Is my watch just messing with me?

4
u/chaosandcalories·

Yeah, I tried tracking my sleep too, and it was all over the place. One night I felt like I was floating on clouds, and the app said I needed more sleep. Guess I just have to rely on coffee!

4
u/midwest_lifter·

i feel you on this. I've had nights where my Apple Watch says I'm well-rested, but I wake up feeling like I got hit by a truck. Maybe it's time to invest in better sleep hygiene instead of relying on tech.

8
u/depressedlifter·

These scores are like trying to predict the weather, bro. One day it's sunny, the next you're getting rained on by anxiety. Maybe it's just a fancy way to sell more watches

7
u/grumpy_gains·

Facts! My watch told me I had a 'fantastic' recovery after a night filled with tossing and turning. I guess it's just confused about my definition of sleep.

6
u/sweaty_warrior·

I think they can be helpful, but we also need to listen to our bodies. I've had 'bad' recovery scores and still crushed my workout the next day. Don't let the numbers dictate how you feel

5
u/grumpy_gains·

I think it's a bit of a scam, honestly. All these devices want to sell you on fancy metrics. Just sleep and lift, don't overthink it!

5
u/depressedlifter·

I feel you, man. Sometimes I think these devices just want to mess with us. Like, one night I'll feel like a zombie, and the watch says I'm well-rested. Total joke.

4
u/grumpy_gains·

My Fitbit once said I had 'poor recovery' after a night of Netflix binging and snacks. But honestly, I crushed a leg day the next morning. Just shows you that these devices can be a bit dramatic.

3
u/midwest_lifter·

Dad joke time: Why did the smartwatch get kicked out of the sleepover? It couldn't stop counting sheep! But seriously, they're all different. I trust how I feel more than the score.

28
u/chickenncarrots·

I feel like wearables are just guessing half the time. I once tracked my sleep after a huge dinner and got a perfect score. Did my lasagna really help me recover? LOL.

23
u/chaosandcalories·

I've actually found that sleep tracking isn't always accurate. It can be more about how I feel in the morning than the numbers say. Ever had that experience?

3
u/chaosandcalories·

Ngl, I still check the scores just to see how far off they are from reality. It's kind of entertaining at this point! Like, who programmed these algorithms?

6
u/weekendwarrior88·

Honestly, tracking sleep can be overwhelming. I think it's better to focus on regular sleep patterns and sticking to a routine. That'll probably lead to better results than stressing over scores.

1
u/squat_to_pizza·

Honestly, if my watch is telling me I'm 'fully recovered' after a night of bad sleep, I just assume it's got a glitch. Let's be real, my body is the real indicator.

13
u/squat_to_pizza·

Maybe the real recovery score is the friends we made along the way. 😂 But for real, it can be frustrating when those scores don't match how you feel.

0
u/nurse_in_the_gym·

It's true that recovery scores can vary, but they can also highlight trends over time. If you notice consistent low scores after certain workouts or stressors, that could guide your recovery efforts. Just don't let it dictate your sleep habits too much.

2
u/6footdadbod·

Every app's got its quirks, but you gotta find what works for you! At the end of the day, if your lifts are improving and you feel good, who cares what the watch says? Just keep at it.

2
Do recovery scores from wearables even make sense? · Repkin