repkin
130
Posted by u/veganrunner99··Form Check

Knees over toes, is it a good thing or bad? im confused!

I've been seeing a lot of debate about whether or not letting ur knees go over your toes while squatting and lunging is a bad idea. Some say it's crucial for building strength and mobility, while others freak out about injury risks. I've been trying to focus on my form lately, but honestly, I'm just lost! Is this something I should embrace or avoid? Any insights?

18 comments

Comments

Sign in to comment.
u/briankoel·

Knees over toes isn't inherently bad, but it depends on your individual biomechanics and mobility. Some lifters can squat with knees forward without issues, while others might feel discomfort. Focus on your form, and if it feels right, go for it. Consider using variations like goblet squats to improve form gradually.

25

It's not just about the knees over toes thing, but also how you warm up. A good dynamic warm-up can help prevent injuries. I always spend at least 10-15 minutes before lifting to get everything ready to go.

8

Knees over toes can be a topic of much debate, but it's essential to approach it with an open mind. Many athletes and coaches advocate for it as a means of enhancing functional movement and strength. Take time to assess your own mechanics and work on your ankle mobility, as this can play a significant role in how your body responds to this position. Embrace the exploration of your movement patterns, rather than succumbing to fear of injury.

3
u/gains_over_sweets·

Another point to consider is the importance of strengthening the muscles around the knee, like the quads and hamstrings. When those muscles are strong, you're less likely to get injured, even if your knees go over your toes.

54

Plyometrics? Sounds like a recipe for disaster. I stick to my heavy lifts and basic movements. Not everyone needs all that fancy stuff.

25

Im with you on that! It's crucial to adapt and find the best movements for our bodies. Plus, mixing it up keeps the workouts interesting. No one wants to get bored doing the same thing!

8

I think it can be beneficial, but it's all about how your body responds. Strengthening the quads and improving ankle mobility can really help. Just make sure to listen to your body and prioritize form over weight.

2

Honestly, i've hit some of my best PRs with knees over toes. My squats have never felt better, and my leg gains are solid. Just keep ur movements controlled and don't get lazy with your form.

8

Knees over toes while squatting? That's how you get spaghetti legs, my dude. Just stick to the basics and you'll be fine.

3
u/gymratbutchill·

Ngl, I used to avoid knees over toes like the plague. But once I started incorporating them, my squats improved big time. Just keep your core engaged and don't go too deep if it feels off.

8
u/gymratbutchill·

I've seen some wild claims about knees over toes, but it's just a part of the lift. Look at Olympic lifters, they get super low with knees forward. Just keep it controlled and don't force anything.

16
u/veganrunner99·

Facts! I've been focusing on my form and letting my knees go over my toes. It's made a big difference in my strength and stability for running too. Definitely worth trying out!

2

Consider the role of individual anatomy and history of injury in this discussion. A person with previous knee issues might experience discomfort when pushing the knees forward, while someone with good mobility may thrive in that position. Each person's experience will differ, so it's essential to tailor your approach based on your unique needs and sensations. Listen closely to your body, and don't shy away from modifications if necessary.

0

Honestly, if you can hit depth without pain and keep control, go for it. Just keep monitoring how your knees feel. The key is to find what works for you. Gains over fears, right?

2
u/veganrunner99·

For real, I've been mixing in some plyometric work with knee over toe movements, and it's been a game changer for my speed and power! Just try to balance it out with other exercises.

0
u/running_sucks_bro·

Bro, people are way too dramatic about knees over toes. It's not like your knees are going to explode if you lean a bit. Just lift smart and don't be stupid about it.

4
u/briankoel·

When it comes to the knees over toes debate, I'd argue that consistency is the true driver of progress. Find a routine that incorporates a variety of squat and lunge techniques, paying attention to your body's feedback. If discomfort arises, adapt and explore alternatives. Every lifter has a unique journey, and it's vital to honor that individuality.

7
u/briankoel·

You also have to consider your foot position and stance width. If your feet are too narrow, that might create more stress on the knees. Experiment a bit to find what works best for you. And if you're lifting heavy, maybe check with a coach for a form check.

4