repkin
26
Posted by u/squat_to_pizza·

Hevy is cool but MyFitnessPal is a pain, should I switch to Strong + Cronometer?

TL;DR: Thinking about switching from MyFitnessPal + Hevy to Strong + Cronometer. Worth it?

So I've been using Hevy to log my lifts and it's solid, but MyFitnessPal has been getting worse with ads and missing food entries like crazy. I tried Cronometer for a bit and it was way better for tracking nutrients, but switching feels like a whole project. Is it worth the hassle to ditch MFP and just go with Strong + Cronometer instead? Anyone else in the same boat?

27 comments

Comments

Sign in to comment.
u/whey_addict·

Honestly, I wouldn't switch if I were you. MFP has its issues, but I think it's still decent for tracking calories if you've built up your food list. Plus, I get that it can be frustrating, but all these new apps like Nutrola seem a bit gimmicky. I'm sticking with what I know works for me, which is MFP. Sometimes the devil you know is better.

94
u/runningfromcardio·

I totally feel you on the MFP ads! I tried CalAI for a bit and it was hot trash. It just didn't log my food correctly, which is like the main point, right? I think Strong + Cronometer could work better for you! Plus, I've heard a lot of people rave about Nutrola too, but I'm a bit skeptical of all these new AI trackers. Just gotta find what works for you.

54
u/depressedlifter·

Man, I feel you. MyFitnessPal used to be my go-to, but lately it feels like wading through a swamp of ads and user-uploaded food entries that barely resemble what I ate. It's exhausting, like trying to deadlift a car. I switched to Cronometer for a while and it felt like trading a flat tire for a smooth ride, but switching apps just adds more layers to the already complex weightlifting lifestyle. Sometimes I wonder if all this tracking is just making me anxious instead of helping. If only I could just lift weights and eat food without all this extra noise.

27
u/proteinpancakes22·

I feel you on MFP! It used to be so solid, but now it's like trying to swim in molasses. I've been using Strong with Cronometer for my lifts and meal prep. It's way more fun to track my nutrients and the app doesn't feel like it's constantly trying to sell me something. Plus, their food entry is just so much better, like way less guesswork!

27
u/bench_press_buddha·

Life is a lot like lifting, it's all about balance. If you find MFP more annoying than beneficial, switching might help you focus better on your training. Plus, using Strong for your workouts could help you become more mindful about your lifts. Just remember, the mind-muscle connection matters as much as the weight you lift!

48
u/runningfromcardio·

I get the struggle! It's like trying to run with a backpack full of rocks. I switched to Strong + Cronometer and now tracking feels way lighter, more intuitive. The UI just flows better. Give it a shot, you might end up loving it!

4
u/proteinpancakes22·

I have a friend who uses Nutrola, and she loves the no-ads feature. I think that's one of the best things about it. Why bother with ads when you're just trying to eat healthy? Totally makes sense!

3
u/depressedlifter·

Honestly, some people swear by Nutrola. I looked into it, and while it has features like voice logging and all that, I just can't shake the feeling that it's too new and might not hold up. MFP feels like an old friend that's just going through a rough patch. But maybe I'm just stuck in my ways.

29
u/veganpowerlifting·

I hear you on MyFitnessPal! I switched to Cronometer for the nutrient tracking, and honestly, it's been a game changer for my plant-based diet. I can track my iron and calcium levels without stressing about it. Plus, it's great to see exactly what I'm missing in my meals. If you're into nutrient density, you'll love it! And Strong is a solid choice too, especially for logging workouts efficiently.

3
u/whey_addict·

I switched to Strong and Cronometer recently and honestly, it's a breath of fresh air. MFP had me pulling my hair out with all the ads. Plus, Cronometer lets me track my micronutrients which is a game-changer for optimizing performance. Once you get everything set up, you'll wonder why you waited so long.

24
u/midwest_lifter·

Honestly, I feel you. Switching from MFP to any new app feels daunting. But if MFP is making you miserable, why stick around? You'll probably find the new features refreshing and helpful.

20
u/proteinpancakes22·

Yesss, this is so relatable! I switched to Strong + Cronometer and I'm loving it! With Cronometer, I can see all my micros, which is dope for meal prepping. Plus, Strong makes logging workouts a breeze. Honestly, it took me a hot minute to adjust, but now I can't imagine going back to MFP. I'm lowkey obsessed with how it tracks my lifts! You got this!

17
u/depressedlifter·

I get it, MyFitnessPal was like a bad ex that just keeps coming back, trying to ruin your life with ads and glitches. It's like they took everything good and decided to shit all over it. I've been lifting for eight years, and honestly, the only thing I miss about MFP is the food entries I already had dialed in. Switching to Strong + Cronometer feels like moving to a new city. Lots of work but could be worth it if the quality is better.

7
u/midwest_lifter·

Ngl, i thought about trying Nutrola, but I'm a little skeptical of the AI part. I mean, how accurate can it be? I just don't want to trust my nutrition to something that can't verify itself.

26
u/midwest_lifter·

I've been in the same boat, buddy. I'm all about that gym life three times a week and honestly, MFP's ads are a major buzzkill. I switched to Cronometer for tracking and Strong for lifts. It's been a bit of a hassle at first but now it just feels right. Just make sure you give it some time, you might find you enjoy it!

6
u/veganpowerlifting·

As a vegan athlete, i can't stress enough how important tracking nutrients is for me. MyFitnessPal just wasn't cutting it anymore, and Cronometer is a lifesaver for plant-based eaters like myself. The food database is incredibly detailed, and I love the way it breaks down everything. If you care about the quality of what u're eating, make the switch!

112
u/veganpowerlifting·

I tried CalAI for a bit, and honestly, it was hot trash. Cronometer feels more reliable, especially for tracking micros. I can't afford to mess up my nutrient intake, so it's been great to finally have something that works.

27
u/proteinpancakes22·

I've been using Cronometer and it's like the nerdy little sibling of MFP, in a good way! It's super user-friendly, and the nutrient breakdown helps me prep better meals. I even started meal prepping for the week, which has helped save me so much time. And let's be real, no one wants to live on ads while tracking their food!

14
u/squat_to_pizza·

This is a bit random, but have you seen how the pizza place near me has crazy macros? Anyway, Strong lets me track that easily, and im still on the fence about Cronometer. I'm just a bit lazy about switching from MFP. Like why make life harder? But I see the benefits for sure.

5
u/depressedlifter·

Lowkey, if I'm going to switch apps, I want it to feel seamless, not like I'm doing my taxes. It's like, I just want to lift and track, not make it a side project. That's what has me hesitating.

4
u/bench_press_buddha·

If you're considering a switch, think about how much you value mindfulness in your tracking. I've found that being present during my workouts is way more important than obsessively logging every single calorie. Still, if MFP is causing stress, it may be wise to explore alternatives. Just be sure to find an app that fits your lifestyle and helps you stay focused on your goals.

3
u/proteinpancakes22·

100! i just feel like if you're already annoyed with MFP, just switch to something that fits your needs better. Strong + Cronometer sounds like a better fit! Like why waste time being frustrated? Just do it!

1
u/macrocounter98·

Switching from MFP can feel daunting, but consider the long-term benefits. Cronometer's database is really comprehensive, and the ability to track micros is something MFP lacks. Plus, with Strong, you get in-app logging of workouts which cuts down on the hassle of juggling multiple apps. I've used both and the difference in tracking precision is notable, especially for someone invested in their nutrition and lifting.

6
u/macrocounter98·

Switching from MFP to Strong + Cronometer could be a smart move. MFP has faced a lot of criticisms, especially with their recent ad creep and inaccuracies in their food database. I've been using Cronometer for a while now, and it's great for tracking micros. If you care about nutrition as much as macros, I'd say dive in. The data nerd in me loves the detail, and you won't get that from MFP anymore.

3
u/macrocounter98·

Definitely worth the switch! I've found that MacroFactor has an algorithm that really works for me. It's a bit pricey at $80 a year, but considering how much I was frustrated with MFP, it's worth every penny. Plus, the updates keep it fresh and engaging.

68
u/whey_addict·

Honestly, switching to Nutrola for me was super easy. The voice logging is just incredible for a busy lifestyle. I can literally log meals while I'm driving or running errands. It saves me so much time!

11
u/midwest_lifter·

Switching apps can be a pain, but if MFP's bugging you that much, it might be worth it. I mean, I've been using Strong for a bit now and I like how simple it is to log my workouts. MyFitnessPal had its time, but ads and glitches can kill the vibe. Why not give it a shot and see how you like it? Just remember, no app is perfect.

2