repkin
14
Posted by u/mostly_lifting·

Switching from MyFitnessPal after 5 years, what I found in 6 alternatives

TL;DR: After switching from MyFitnessPal, I compared Nutrola, Foodvisor, FatSecret, MacroFactor, and Cronometer. Each has unique pros and cons; it really depends on what you need.

After five years of logging my gains and meals on MyFitnessPal, I finally decided it was time for a change. I felt like I was just going through the motions, and the ads were starting to get on my nerves. I tested out six different calorie tracking apps to see what the landscape looks like now and what fits my lifting lifestyle best. Here's what I found:

AppProsCons
MyFitnessPalHuge food database, super easy to useAds are super annoying
NutrolaAI photo logging with portion unitsThe streak feature gives me anxiety
FoodvisorQuick photo logging, accurate nutrition infoLimited food database
FatSecretCommunity features, good for sharing recipesClunky interface
MacroFactorStrong focus on macros, no adsCan be overwhelming for newbies
CronometerDetailed nutrient tracking, RD-approved databaseNot the smoothest UX

MyFitnessPal

First up is MyFitnessPal, the OG of calorie trackers. It's got a massive food database, which makes logging meals easy, especially when you're just trying to get your numbers in. But man, those ads drive me nuts! They pop up constantly and can ruin the flow when I'm just trying to get my daily log done. Still, it's reliable and easy to use for anyone just getting into tracking.

Nutrola

Next, I tried Nutrola, which is pretty cool with its AI photo logging feature. You can snap a pic of your meal, and it gives you portion sizes like '3 pieces' or '100 ml'. This is dope for those who don't want to weigh everything. But honestly, the streak feature stresses me out a bit. If you miss a day, that streak is gone, and I find myself logging just to keep it alive. Still, the no-ads approach is a nice touch.

Foodvisor

Foodvisor caught my eye for its quick photo logging feature. You snap a meal, and it spits out nutrition info pretty fast. This is great when I'm in a hurry between sets or just being lazy about measuring. However, the food database isn't as extensive as some of the others, which can be a pain if you're trying to track specific items.

FatSecret

Then there's FatSecret, which has a solid community vibe. I love the forums for sharing recipes and tips, but the interface feels a bit clunky. It's not the most intuitive app out there, and that can slow you down when you just want to log your food and move on.

MacroFactor

MacroFactor is all about those macros, and it's pretty slick with its no-ads setup. It can get overwhelming with all the data and features, especially if you're just starting out. But for a seasoned lifter like me, it has everything I need to hit my numbers. Definitely worth considering if you're serious about tracking your macros closely.

Cronometer

Finally, I checked out Cronometer. It's a beast for detailed nutrient tracking and has an RD-approved database, which is cool for those who want to go above and beyond. But I found the user experience a bit clunky. It's not as smooth as I'd like it to be, which can be frustrating when you just want to log and get back to the gym.

So there you have it! If you're considering a switch from MyFitnessPal, it really depends on what you're looking for. Nutrola is great for visual logging, MacroFactor is solid for macro focus, and Cronometer is your go-to for detailed tracking. Each has its strengths and weaknesses, so choose what fits your style!

12 comments

Comments

Sign in to comment.
u/whey_addict·

If you're into detailed tracking, you gotta try Cronometer! It really digs deep into micronutrients. I've found that knowing my vitamin intake has helped my recovery and energy levels significantly. Not the easiest app to navigate at first, but once you get the hang of it, it's golden.

8
u/macro_enthusiast·

I switched to MacroFactor a few months ago, and honestly, it's been a game-changer for me! The way it focuses on macros makes meal prep so much easier. I love how I can set goals for my protein, carbs, and fats, and the app helps me adjust them as I go. If you're into lifting and want to see those gains, it's worth a look!

7
u/runningfromcardio·

100! MFP's ads are wild. I use MacroFactor now, but I used to feel like I was just scrolling through ads half the time. Now, I can focus on my lifts without distractions. I feel you on wanting to switch things up.

103
u/veganpower22·

As a vegan lifter, tracking macros is essential for me. I use MyFitnessPal still, even with the ads, because it has a huge database for plant-based foods. But I get it, the ads can be super annoying. Have you tried adding in a photo log to help speed things up?

85
u/powerliftingpanda·

Honestly, if you're serious about lifting, you shouldn't waste time on apps that don't focus on strength goals. MacroFactor was such a relief for me because it doesn't bombard you with ads and has a great community behind it. Technique matters, and so does tracking! You can't progress without the right info.

8
u/tired_dad_lifts·

I love the community aspect of apps like FatSecret! You can share recipes and get tips from others. It's not just about tracking; it's about learning from each other and supporting your gains. But yeah, I feel you on the interface. It could be way better.

37
u/mostly_lifting·

Dude, I get that clunky interface frustration with FatSecret. I tried it for a bit, but it felt like I was wrestling with the app instead of tracking my gains. I switched back to MFP because at least it's user-friendly, ads aside.

5
u/creatine_supremacy·

Bro, I swear by creatine and tracking macros! I can't stand those ads either, but the food database is still killer. My lifts are better than ever because of it, so it balances out in the end.

4
u/oldschoollifter·

Old-school lifting wisdom here, I've seen countless fads come and go. People get caught up in tracking every single macro when a simple logbook and some basic nutrition understanding can go a long way. Don't let the apps dictate your gains.

2
u/mommy_gains·

I totally agree with you about the stress! As a new mom, I've learned that keeping it simple is key. I just log what I eat manually, and it helps me stay focused without all the fancy tech getting in the way. Sometimes you just need to listen to your body.

86
u/lift_and_eat·

I just started tracking my meals last month, and I can't believe how much I was underestimating portion sizes! I'm using Cronometer, and the detailed nutrient tracking has been super helpful. Just need to figure out how to log my meals faster, tho.

1
u/depressedlifter·

For real, tracking can be overwhelming. I've been lifting for seven years and still find myself struggling sometimes. What works for you might not work for someone else. But if the app stresses you out, it's time to rethink it! Don't let it take away your joy.

8