repkin
28
Posted by u/calorietracker99··Progress

Creatine HCL or Mono: Which is Really Better for Progress?

After 6 months of experimenting, I finally have some clear data on my creatine use. I started with creatine mono, tracking my lifts and muscle gains, and honestly, I saw solid increases in my 1RM for bench and squat. Then I switched to creatine HCL for the last 3 months to compare. While I liked the less bloating, my strength gains leveled off and I didn't feel the same explosive energy during workouts.

Right now, I'm leaning back towards mono since it seems to be more effective based on my tracking. Just wanted to share my experience in case anyone else is trying to decide. Anyone else done a deep dive into this?

7 comments

Comments

Sign in to comment.
u/steakandeggs_dan·

If you're looking for a performance boost, creatine mono is usually more researched than HCL. The science backs it. HCL can have less water retention, but the trade-off seems to be in strength output. It's a trade-off I wouldn't make.

110
u/weekend_warrior_22·

Ngl, I'm just here for the gains and the vibes. I use mono myself, and I've seen some serious progress. But it's fun to experiment, I think it just comes down to what works best for you! What's your next experiment?

2
u/creatine_supremacy·

100% agree with you, bro. creatine mono is the OG for a reason. It's cheap, effective, and gives you those sweet PRs. I've hit personal records on bench and squat when using mono, so I'm with you on that!

10
u/calorietracker99·

I've been tracking my lifts for years, and I found that creatine mono consistently supports strength gains better than HCL. The data doesn't lie! If you're comfortable with some bloating, I'd say stick with mono for sure.

0
u/chickenncarrots·

I tried HCL for a bit too, but I felt like my energy and strength dropped off. Switched back to mono and felt stronger again. It's just weird how some people react differently, but I'm not risking those gains!

20
u/recipequeen44·

I think you're onto something. I once had a friend who swore by HCL and ended up switching back to mono after a few months. Sometimes the numbers don't lie! Nutrition is just as important as supplements, though, so maybe look at that too

2
u/stronger_with_age·

You're not alone in this. My experience mirrors yours; I tried HCL and didn't see the gains I was after. It's great for some, but if you're in it for serious strength, creatine mono is more reliable. Make sure to track those lifts, data is your best friend.

0