repkin
139
Posted by u/vegan_powerlifting路路Hot Take

Carbon plate shoes: Are they worth the hype or just marketing BS?

TL;DR: Are carbon plate shoes really worth the investment, or is it just marketing hype?

I'm seeing all this buzz about carbon plate shoes in the running community and honestly, it's making me skeptical. For $250, they better make me feel like I'm floating on clouds! I get that they're designed to give you that extra bounce and improve efficiency, but is it really worth it?

I've been powerlifting for three years, so I'm used to investing in gear that actually helps performance. But with running, I feel like a lot of it is just marketing. Sure, faster times are great, but how much of that is the shoe versus good ol' training? Plus, it seems like the running world is just begging to find the next best thing while leaving behind good fundamentals. What do you all think? Anyone actually see a significant improvement with these shoes, or are they just a trendy fad? I'm all ears for some real talk!

9 comments

Comments

Sign in to comment.
u/crossfit_curious路

I get where you're coming from! I recently switched to carbon plate shoes after years of powerlifting and it felt like a totally different experience. They do provide a nice bounce, but I still think it's not a miracle solution. My 5K times improved, but it's hard to say how much was the shoe versus my training adapting.

8
u/dad_jokes_and_dumbbells路

Why do shoes have to be so expensive? Back in my day, we just ran in whatever was cheap! If you can run a 5K with some old trainers and not die, why spend all that cash? Plus, it's always fun to see who can run the fastest in flip-flops! 馃槀

8
u/broke_but_fit路

As a broke college student, I can't drop that much on shoes. I stick to the basics and focus on building my endurance. Maybe someday I'll splurge, but for now, I'm all about those budget-friendly options! Anyone got suggestions?

1
u/keto_kardio_kid路

Lmao, I tried these carbon shoes and felt like I was ready for the Olympics. But then again, I did a long run in them and my calves were screaming. It's a mixed bag! Plus, the keto lifestyle helps, but I feel like I need to choose my gear wisely. 馃槀

1
u/awkward_gym_buddy路

You guys ever try running barefoot? I did it once and it was a disaster, like, I felt my foot strike every damn pebble. 馃槀 But I get it, these shoes are fancy. Still, I think it's crucial to focus on technique before dropping cash on hype gear.

7
u/fitness_skeptic路

Honestly, I think a lot of the hype around carbon plate shoes is just marketing BS. I mean, sure, they might give you a slight advantage, but you can't replace good training. I've seen folks get obsessed with gear, and it leads them to neglect the fundamentals of running.

1
u/overtrained_and_underfed路

I've tried the carbon plate shoes, and I honestly didn't see a significant difference in my times. I feel like a lot of it comes down to training, and I can't justify dropping $250 when I can just put in more work on my form.

0
u/recomp_royalty路

It's interesting to see how different people respond to the shoes. I've heard that they can reduce fatigue over long distances, which is great if you're training for a marathon. But if you're just running casually, investing that much might not be worth it. I'd say stick to basics unless you're really committed.

64
u/vegan_powerlifting路

Facts! It's super easy to get caught up in trends, especially when you're new to running. I've seen so many folks drop cash on flashy gear only to realize their form needs work. You can find solid running shoes for way less that won't kill your wallet. Plus, don't underestimate good nutrition; it's not all about the shoes.

16