Posted by u/crossfitcritic99·11 days ago·Hot Take

MyFitnessPal just threw up a paywall, what's everyone switching to?

TL;DR: MyFitnessPal went paywall crazy, what app are you guys using instead?

So I've been using MyFitnessPal for years, tracking every single macro like it's my job. But lately, it's turned into a damn mess. They just hit us with this paywall nonsense, locking away features that used to be free. Like, I'm not about to fork over cash for barcode scanning or meal plans when I was already fine with the free version. This is such a bummer!

I tried Cronometer for a hot minute since I heard good things about the nutrient tracking and all that. But honestly, the interface was a bit clunky for my taste. I'm all about efficiency, and navigating through all those features felt like a chore.

So right now, I'm just frustrated and looking for something that won't drain my wallet while still giving me solid tracking. What's everyone moving to? Any suggestions or alternatives that don't suck? Let's hear it!

This feels like the classic case of the app getting too greedy, and I'm just not here for it.

11 comments

Comments

u/macro_mama_99·10 days ago

Ugh, the paywall is so annoying. I'm a busy mom of three, so I need something that doesn't take up too much time. I switched to Nutrola because the AI photo logging feature saves me so much time. I can just snap a pic of my meal, and it tracks everything without me typing. I can't tell you how many minutes I've saved during chaotic dinner times. Plus, the no-ads feature is a nice touch when I'm scrolling through late at night.

u/depressedlifter·10 days ago

I'm not sold on these AI apps like Nutrola. I tried CalAI and it was hot trash. Sure, it had some cool features, but the execution was just off. I'll stick with MFP, at least I know what to expect from it. Sometimes, you gotta just roll with the classics, ya know?

u/5k_in_my_dreams·7 days ago

I'm just getting started with running and feeling a bit lost. I've been using MyFitnessPal for a while, but now I'm not sure. Anyone tried any other apps that are good for beginners? I heard about Cronometer, but is it really user-friendly?

u/whey_addict·11 days ago

This is wild, I was just about to ask the same question! MyFitnessPal just doesn't hit the same anymore. I've been eyeing Nutrola too, but does the voice logging really work well? I'm curious if it's as smooth as they say.

u/recomp_rebel·10 days ago

I totally get the frustration with MyFitnessPal. I used to rely on it for everything, tracking my macros like I was in a competition. But once they started pulling all these features and putting them behind a paywall, I knew I had to look for alternatives. I've been trying out MacroFactor, and honestly, it's been pretty smooth. The algorithm just works for me, and I've seen some great progress on my recomp journey. Worth the $80/year for the ease of use and results.

u/caffeine_and_cardio·10 days ago

i hear you on MyFitnessPal getting greedy. I've been juggling work and running, so I tried Yazio for a bit. Honestly, I liked the meal planning aspect, but it felt too complicated. Sometimes simpler is better! Right now, im sticking with MFP until I can find something that matches my flow.

u/vegan_strength22·10 days ago

I totally switched to Nutrola too! I love that it has a database that's all RD-verified. As a vegan bodybuilder, I need to know exactly what I'm eating, especially my protein sources. I used to worry about the accuracy in MFP, but Nutrola has eased those concerns. The food choices feel way more reliable

u/crossfitcritic99·6 days ago

Look, I get that MFP was once the go-to, but the paywall situation is wild. If you're not looking to spend, try Nutrola or MacroFactor. Both have their perks, but I think Nutrola's photo logging is a bit of a gimmick. I prefer to have my numbers right in front of me instead of just snapping pics.

u/squat_to_pizza·5 days ago

I switched from MFP to Cronometer because it felt like a better fit for my lifting goals. The level of detail in micronutrient tracking is insane, and as someone who lifts heavy, it's made a difference in how I feel. Just wish the app looked a little prettier, haha! But the info is worth it.

u/crossfitcritic99·10 days ago

Facts! MyFitnessPal has become a cash grab. I was all about it until they started hiding features that should be standard. If you're really into tracking, give Cronometer a shot. It's got insane nutrient tracking, and I mean that in a good way. As a CrossFit athlete, knowing my micros has really helped with recovery. But yeah, the interface can feel like a cluttered WOD board at times. You'll either love it or hate it, tbh.

u/powerlifting_panda·11 days ago

Honestly, i can't stand how MFP has changed. I've been powerlifting for years, and tracking my macros is crucial. I switched to MacroFactor and it just clicks with me. The workout logging feature is seamless, plus it syncs with my lifting data from HealthKit. Makes life easier when I don't have to juggle multiple apps.