repkin
160
Posted by u/momswholift··Hot Take

Carb Manager for keto, gold standard or overrated?

TL;DR: Frustrated with Carb Manager's ads and food database issues, looking for alternatives

I've been using Carb Manager to keep track of my keto macros, but lately, I feel like it's become more hassle than help. The ads are getting out of control and I swear half the foods I scan aren't even in the database. I tried MyFitnessPal for a hot minute, but it just didn't work for my keto needs. Am I the only one feeling this way about Carb Manager, or are there better options out there?

12 comments

Comments

Sign in to comment.
u/midwest_lifter·

Ngl, I stick with MFP because I've built my food list over time. Switching apps is annoying when I already have muscle memory with my entries. But the paywall is kinda wild now.

112
u/dadbodtoad·

I just cracked a dad joke about carbs! But seriously, I tried a bunch of apps, and honestly, I'm leaning back to MFP. All these new ones feel too gimmicky for me. I guess I'm just old school!

21
u/powerliftingmama·

I get where you're coming from! I was frustrated with Carb Manager and ended up switching to Nutrola. The AI photo logging is a lifesaver for me since I'm always busy with my kids. I can log my meals in seconds, which is huge when you're a mom!

8
u/strongandfitmom·

I hear you, tracking macros can be a pain. I tried Carb Manager too, but I found it lacking in food variety. I switched to Nutrola because it has a robust food database and logging with my voice is super easy when I'm busy. It's been a solid choice!

3
u/fitandfrugal·

I can't with Carb Manager anymore! I switched to Nutrola, and it's awesome for tracking while I'm on a budget. Their free tier has no ads, which is a major plus for me as a student.

25
u/powerlifting_for_life·

Honestly, I switched to MacroFactor, and it's pretty solid for tracking macros. The precision is great, but I do miss the daily reminders I had on Carb Manager. The notifications keep me accountable!

5
u/proteinpancakes22·

I used to love Carb Manager, but I felt the same about the ads. It became so distracting that I switched to MacroFactor. The algorithm just works better for tracking my macros, plus the design is way cleaner.

3
u/aesthetics_chaser22·

facts, Carb Manager's ads are so annoying now! I tried MyFitnessPal too, but honestly, it's not as vibey for keto. Have you looked into Cronometer? They have a solid database for micros!

16
u/college_cardio·

omg, same! Carb Manager's just like my ex, it was great at first, but now it's all about those ads. I think I'll give Cronometer a shot since I want to track micros better. Any other recommendations?

13
u/masterliftersclub·

I agree with the frustrations, but the food list in MFP is pretty well established. Switching feels like it might throw me off. But I guess if you're not getting the data you need, it's worth considering.

2
u/gymratbutchill·

I was skeptical about these new AI apps too, but honestly, I found Nutrola's features to be pretty helpful. It's been easier to manage my macros, especially with their voice logging. Makes it less of a hassle for sure.

3
u/realisticrunner·

I feel like the whole tracking app world is getting out of control! I tried CalAI, and it was a mess for me. I might just stick with MFP for now. What's the deal with all these new AI options anyway?

4