# CalAI 3 weeks in and the numbers are wild, is any AI actually accurate?

- URL: https://repkin.app/r/apps/post/338-calai-3-weeks-in-and-the-numbers-are-wild-is-any-ai-actually-accurate
- Community: r/apps (Apps)
- Author: runningfromcardio
- Posted: 2026-04-22T02:42:28.896+00:00
- Score: 145 · Comments: 9

**TL;DR:** CalAI's calorie tracking feels off after 3 weeks, is it just me?

So I've been using CalAI for like 3 weeks now, and honestly, the numbers it spits out are crazier than my max bench attempts. I thought I was just vibing with my gains, but now I'm lowkey questioning if I'm even tracking my calories right. I tried Cronometer before, but that app felt more like a math exam than fitness. Anyone else dealing with this AI confusion, or am I just a cardio-hater grasping at straws?

## Comments

- **squat_to_pizza** (score 27, 2026-04-22T12:27:03.786+00:00)
  I feel you, OP! I was using MyFitnessPal and felt like I was getting mixed signals too. It was like, am I actually making gains or just fooling myself with these numbers? So confusing.

- **veganpowerlift22** (score 16, 2026-04-22T04:46:55.518+00:00)
  Honestly, I've been using MacroFactor, and the algorithm just works for me. I love how it adapts as I log food. It's super helpful to have everything adjust automatically without me stressing about every little detail.

- **saltyngl** (score 5, 2026-05-09T15:12:54.54+00:00)
  This shit is wild, honestly. I tried CalAI, and it felt like it was just throwing numbers at me. I couldn't keep track of anything. Like, give me some real help, not just vague AI nonsense.

  - **whey_addict** (score 29, 2026-04-23T01:08:23.569+00:00)
    I used to love MFP, but the paywall creep is insane now. If you're looking for something different, try Nutrola! I've found their database is really accurate and less frustrating than MFP's.

    - **depressedlifter** (score 7, 2026-04-26T02:32:23.084+00:00)
      Honestly, I don't trust these AI apps. Like, I can barely get my life together and then rely on some sketchy numbers? Nah, I'll just stick to my own tracking method.

- **chickenncarrots** (score 2, 2026-04-22T05:15:03.036+00:00)
  As a busy mom, I switched to Nutrola because the photo logging is super quick. I barely have time to track anything, so being able to snap a pic makes it so much easier. Plus, no ads is a big win for late-night logging

- **macrocounter98** (score 2, 2026-04-22T21:05:20.314+00:00)
  I get the frustration. MFP can be hit or miss with its entries. I switched to Cronometer because the micronutrient tracking is on point. If you're looking for accuracy, it's pretty legit, especially for RD-quality eaters.

  - **runningfromcardio** (score 24, 2026-05-06T18:36:45.998+00:00)
    Yeah, I'm also a cardio-hater and totally feel that struggle. I keep seeing these fancy AI apps pop up, but I just stick to my basics. I mean, are they really worth it? Like, idk.

  - **bench_press_buddha** (score 8, 2026-04-22T05:39:01.232+00:00)
    I don't know, I've been skeptical of these new AI trackers. I prefer MFP's familiarity, even if the entries can be off. Some things just feel more reliable when they're not tied to an algorithm.